A tale of two decisions

GettyImages

Michael Carrick gets treatment as Steven Gerrard is dismissed

Scoring Summary

Manchester United	Liverpool
Ryan Giggs (2')

Match Stats

Manchester United

Liverpool

16(10)	Shots (on Goal)	13(5)
11	Fouls	7
11	Corner Kicks	3
3	Offsides	2
58%	Time of Possession	42%
2	Yellow Cards	0
0	Red Cards	1
4	Saves	9

Teams

Manchester United	Liverpool
29 Tomasz Kuszczak	25 Pepe Reina
5 Rio Ferdinand	6 Fabio Aurelio
3 Patrice Evra	5 Daniel Agger
21 Rafael	37 Martin Skrtel
23 Jonathan Evans	34 Martin Kelly
16 Michael Carrick	8 Steven Gerrard
11 Ryan Giggs	4 Raul Meireles
24 Darren Fletcher	21 Lucas
17 Nani	17 Maximiliano Rodriguez
9 Dimitar Berbatov	18 Dirk Kuyt
14 Javier Hernández	9 Fernando Torres
Substitutes
34 Anders Lindegaard	Peter Gulacsi 42
12 Chris Smalling	Sotirios Kyrgiakos 16
20 Fabio Da Silva	Danny Wilson 22
28 Darron Gibson	Christian Poulsen 28
8 Anderson	Jonjo Shelvey 33
7 Michael Owen	Ryan Babel 19
26 Gabriel Obertan	David Ngog 24
Substitutions
Anderson for Darren Fletcher (62)	Ryan Babel for Maximiliano Rodriguez (60)
Michael Owen for Javier Hernández (75)	Jonjo Shelvey for Raul Meireles (60)
Chris Smalling for Jonathan Evans (84)	David Ngog for Fernando Torres (77)
Yellow Cards
Darren Fletcher (9)
Anderson (64)
Red Cards
	Steven Gerrard (32)
· Squads: Manchester United | Liverpool

Kenny Dalglish failed to get the dream start he was looking for as Manchester United ensured his second stint as the new Liverpool boss began with an FA Cup defeat at Old Trafford.
• Berbatov: It was a penalty
Dalglish arrived from Dubai last night after accepting the challenge of reviving the Merseysiders' fortunes, which have plummeted dramatically in recent times, culminating in Roy Hodgson's dismissal yesterday.
And he certainly brought more conviction to his players and Liverpool's supporters.It will take rather more to create a winning team though, and while Dalglish can take heart from the way his side battled back following Ryan Giggs' controversial second-minute penalty and the dismissal of captain Steven Gerrard for a nasty first-half challenge on Michael Carrick, the Scot knows there is so much work to do.Still, his name brings hope, even if time has moved on since February 22, 1991, when Dalglish resigned in the wake of an epic 4-4 draw with Everton.Indeed, just eight days after Dalglish's dramatic decision to quit the club he will forever be linked with, came another significant day in English football - Giggs' United debut.That Giggs boasts a record 11 Premier League winners' medals, 855 appearances and 157 goals for the Old Trafford outfit just emphasises the time that has elapsed since Dalglish bestrode an Anfield outfit that were still worthy of their status as a football giant.There was a symmetry therefore about Giggs confidently striding up to dispatch a second-minute penalty that punctured so much of the optimism within the Dalglish bubble.Not that the Scot would have been entirely convinced by Howard Webb's penalty award. Few who saw the replay were, although Daniel Agger's unwise decision to stick out a leg did offer Dimitar Berbatov something to fall over.Unfortunately for Dalglish, it was not the last time he had reason to curse Webb, who steered the game towards its eventual outcome with two crucial decisions around the half hour.The first was a non-decision when Rafael thudded into Raul Meireles with a tackle that won the ball, but was also two-footed.Had Webb taken action for that, Gerrard might have thought twice about his own ill-fated lunge.But the World Cup final referee kept his cards in his pocket and waved play on.The same did not apply when Gerrard launched himself into England team-mate Carrick, going over the top of the United man, which Webb deemed reckless enough to merit instant dismissal.Having taken all this into account, and the remainder of an otherwise positive opening 45 minutes for his team, Dalglish loitered for just long enough after the half-time whistle to suggest he might take issue with Webb. In the end, he opted not to bother.The Scot's interval team talk could at least have reflected on decent opportunities for Fernando Torres, denied the chance to exert his superiority over Nemanja Vidic by the United skipper's absence, Gerrard and Maxi Rodriguez.He must also have known that United would dominate possession in the way his own side had done before Gerrard's departure.And if Javier Hernandez had been able to glance Darren Fletcher's right-wing cross into the bottom corner a couple of minutes after the restart, Liverpool would have had nothing worth fighting for anyway.As it turned out, the Mexican was off target. And though Liverpool did spend long periods chasing possession, roused by their supporters, who were gaining their own voice through Dalglish, they refused to give up.Ryan Babel brought a low save out of Tomasz Kuszczak before Fabio Aurelio sent a free-kick curling towards the top corner, forcing the Pole to claw the ball away.It took United some time to re-establish dominance, although when they did, two blocked shots, for Berbatov and Rafael, rejected penalty appeals for Jonny Evans and Giggs, both far more plausible than the one Webb gave, plus an excellent save from Reina to deny Patrice Evra, were scant reward for a thrilling melee.The sight of Michael Owen being introduced for United 16 minutes from time just added another surreal dimension to an amazing day.There was no goal for Owen against his old club, as Anderson and Evra went closest to increasing United's advantage before the final whistle.

Berbatov: It was a penaltyDimitar Berbatov insisted referee Howard Webb was right to award Manchester United a decisive penalty in the first minute of their 1-0 win over 10-man Liverpool in their FA Cup third-round clash at Old Trafford.Berbatov told ITV1: "Of course it was a penalty. There was enough contact for me to lose my balance and people know I do not go to ground easily."I thought Liverpool put in a good performance and I thought their 'keeper Jose Reina was their best player and made some good saves, but we were the better side."The other major talking point of Kenny Dalglish's first game back in charge of the Reds was the sending-off of captain Steven Gerrard just after the half-hour mark.Goalscorer Giggs would not be drawn on the incident, saying: "I couldn't see it myself but the players' reactions tend to tell you a lot and the players round the ball were not too happy and once the decision is made you have to get on with it."That early goal helped us, as did the sending-off, but we had chances to finish off the game and you are a bit nervous when you don't take them."Defensively we looked good and we could have scored more today."Dalglish was less then happy with the two key decisions, but praised his side's commitment after playing an hour of the game a man down."The two decisions are important factors in the game, but if you went into detail about them it would take away from the commitment of the players," he said."It's difficult to come here, they are top of the league and when you are down to 10 men and lose a goal in the first minute you need to show commitment, and the players did that and they had great support here today as well."We also brought three young lads on to try and freshen it up as our guys had put in so much effort."When pressed on the penalty and red card incidents, he added: "I did not think the penalty was a penalty kick."The sending off....Is anyone who leaves the ground to get sent off now? The thing was that Howard Webb stepped away from the incident and then blew his whistle after one of our lads kicked the ball."